Two Viewpoints of the Media’s Portrayal of the Illegal Immigrant Family Separation at the Southern Border

716
Two Viewpoints of the Media's Portrayal of the Illegal Immigrant Family Separation at the Southern Border

Deprecated: Function create_function() is deprecated in /home/freepre8/public_html/wp-content/plugins/wp-spamshield/wp-spamshield.php on line 2033

We’re introducing a new format on Free Press Daily News. In support of our slogan, Decide for yourself, we’re offering two viewpoints on a major topic in one article. Please read both and let us know what you think in a comment below. Thank you.
~ Chad Allen, publisher and managing editor

The Liberal Media is Blowing Illegal Immigrant Family Separation Way out of Proportion

Michael Strong, Conservative Perspective
Michael Strong Conservative Perspective

Witnessing your offspring suffer is one of the most unbearable experiences a parent can endure. Let’s not mince words here; the illegal immigrant family separation happening at the U.S.-Mexican border is an inhumane atrocity that needs to be solved immediately before this becomes yet another one of America’s shameful regrets. While it’s understandably sparking national outrage, you’re not getting the whole story because the liberal media is selectively lying by omission for that very reason.

The detention centers that the children of illegal immigrants are being held has been described as being kept in “cages” often compared to Japanese internment camps during World War II, or even worse hyperbolically called “concentration camps.” Children are not being murdered or starved to death. That dangerous comparison is not only irrational but it also grotesquely minimizes the detriment of the Holocaust.

You’ve probably seen the pictures of children crying in literal metal cages. You’ve heard the stories of infants being literally ripped from their mother while breastfeeding. And you’ve probably heard that ICE has been lying to parents and children that they’re just taking them to get bathed and they will be reunited shortly. None of this is acceptable and should never been implemented during the April memorandum from the attorney general’s office mandating this new “zero tolerance” policy.

Many of those horrifying pictures depicting despicable living conditions like children sleeping with blankets that appear to be aluminum foil.

They quickly circled the web, but those are only from a handful of detention centers. One in El Cajon California looked like a suite at the Four Seasons compared to several in Texas.

Yes, this is anecdotal but Ingraham is right that although the living conditions are far better than the others, ripping children away from their parents still isn’t good enough. No amount of amenities can justify the fear of a child not knowing where the future lies.

You may have also seen a picture of a mural at one detention center that featured President Trump’s photo and a quote that said, “Sometimes by losing a battle you find a new way to win the war.” The liberal media presented this as if it was a dictator’s fear mongering message. But it’s actually just a quote from his book “The Art of the Deal,” and he’s not the only president to have a mural in a detention center. Obama, JFK and Abraham Lincoln had their own in the Brownsville center.

Separating children from their parents, on the surface, appears to be undeniably cruel, but it’s just part of the due diligence. Some of these illegal immigrants are genuinely seeking asylum, but this is an unfortunate crucial part of the process to protect the child so they can determine whether their claim is true or not.

And this isn’t exclusive towards illegal immigrants crossing the border where the parents are charged with a misdemeanor, American citizens can undergo the same family-separation treatment when they commit a crime as well. If the parents are proven to have been abusive or neglectful for a litany of reasons – including being charged with some misdemeanors – then their child is placed in Child Protective Services’ custody. One might argue that the circumstances between the gamble of an illegal immigrant crossing the southern border to save their child from abuse and an American citizen’s neglectful behavior are vastly incomparable. But the illegal immigrant must be aware that there is a process – and a long one at that.

That’s not to say the process can’t be fixed because the wheel is definitely broken in this scenario. Although it can be improved, it’s not a “concentration camp.”

Rebuttal:

The Right Wing Media is Actively Downplaying the Severity of Illegal Immigrant Family Separation

Jennifer Slate, Liberal Perspective
By Jennifer Slate Liberal Perspective

President Trump’s administration and the right wing media are demonizing illegal immigrants with a broad stroke. By blanketing every migrant who crosses the border illegally as being criminals, it allows Trump’s base to justify the cruelty of family separation.

Many of these families coming across the border are actively seeking asylum. They are not trekking hundreds or even thousands of miles for the dream of making it in America. They are fleeing dangerous crime-ridden areas for protection against physical danger in their home country.

One thing perpetuated by the right wing media, from Fox News to the alt-right abominations like Breitbart and TownHall, is that it’s totally simple to just apply for asylum at the U.S. embassy in Mexico instead of crossing the border illegally. That’s a bold faced lie and they know it. They know exactly what they’re doing – crossing their fingers, hoping, they won’t do the adequate research and just take their word for it.

Turning Point USA, a conservative right wing nonprofit founded by Charlie Kirk, recently wrote on Twitter:

This tweet has over 31,000 likes and the information couldn’t be further from the truth.

The reality is that U.S. embassies or consulates cannot process applications for those that seek asylum or refugee status. The only way to seek asylum status is by crossing the border, which is illegal. It’s a double-edge sword for many of them and it’s plausible to say that they had no idea that seeking asylum would become more malicious in the last several months. The Trump administration and attorney general implement issued a policy in April – giving ICE free reign to enforce illegal immigrant family separation – with many of these children being infants.

Right wing media has either become grossly incompetent or they are actively deceiving their viewers to perpetuate falsehoods, and in turn, weaponizing their viewers against liberals who find this policy profoundly harsh and a violation of human rights.

Fox News’ Tucker Carlson is undoubtedly one of the biggest deceivers.

Carlson recently warned to his millions of his viewers at the height of the illegal immigration family separation, “If you’re looking to understand what’s actually happening in this country, always assume the opposite of whatever they’re telling you on the big news stations.” Ironically, Fox News is the biggest news station. But encouraging his fan base that he – and the rest of Fox News – is the only station that’s telling the truth is a violation of ethical journalism. And they know it.

Many images of the detention centers along the Texas-Mexico border have been leaked that shows children sleeping in blankets that appear to be aluminum foil, children crying in cages and audio files of children crying for their parents.

Here’s one such audio that was recently released.

It’s the right wing media’s job to take a horrifying audio file like this and somehow spin it to justify that there’s good reason for this abomination. They’ve been throwing around rhetoric that criminals who are American citizens have their children taken away from them if they commit a crime. When the parents cross the border they are immediately charged with a misdemeanor, but the only way to legally seek asylum is by committing a crime to do so.

The right wing media perpetuates to conservatives that they should have zero empathy for these children and they are surprisingly doing a great job at what is unarguably inhumane.

Which viewpoint do you agree with, and why? Let us know in a comment below.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here